Disclosure: This Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan page contains affiliate links. Read full Disclosure Policy.

Wow! We found the Best Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan Rentals. Save time searching!

Best Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan Rentals


30 Dreamy Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan Rentals


Incredible Recommendations for Every Style & Budget


Dreaming about a trip to New Buffalo, Michigan?

Save time on your Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan rental search, including our recommendations for best New Buffalo, Michigan Airbnb choices.

Selection Criteria

WHERE TO STAY New Buffalo, Michigan

We searched every New Buffalo, Michigan neighborhood for the best Airbnb rentals in New Buffalo, Michigan…so you wouldn’t have to! In this comprehensive New Buffalo, Michigan vacation rentals guide, we only recommend the best New Buffalo, Michigan Airbnb deals.

The properties we show here were selected based on a combination of the following factors: the number of Airbnb reviews of the property itself, the quality of the host, the location, and its relative comparison to other New Buffalo, Michigan Airbnb rentals.

5 Secrets to Save Money on Your Airbnb Rentals

FREE EMAIL COURSE
5 little-known tricks to save money on Airbnb.
Ideas, advice & hacks!

Get the Secrets Now

Search the Best Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan Options


We have found 30 DREAMY New Buffalo, Michigan Airbnb options for you. Organized in order of price, we're confident we've found a magical option for your next trip.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Wow! We found the Best Airbnb New Buffalo, Michigan Rentals. Save time searching!

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

Why We Love It

Have a nice getaway with your family here in this nicely made house in the middle of the woods. It's a treat for those who appreciate hiking and architecture. It is also conveniently located near restaurants, towns and beaches in Harbor Country.

Rooms

  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Beds: 4
  • Bathrooms: 2
Noteworthy Amenities

  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Parking included
  • Washer / Dryer

Luxury Airbnb Rentals Near New Buffalo, Michigan

Stay in this location and see the beach just across this property! Perfect for big groups of beach bums. It also has well-lit interiors, cozy feels, and guaranteed beautiful views when you go up the tower.

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This space is conveniently located near the beach, meaning a lot of swim time and a chance to admire beautiful sunsets. Interiors and outdoor areas are stylishly decorated for a nice, welcoming feel. It is pet-friendly and also near other shops in case you want to explore.

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 4

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This space is perfect weekend getaway with family or friends! Enjoy the heated pool, hot tub, flat screen TV, doing sports activities, and a whole lot more while surrounded by a bunch of beautiful trees. It's also close to the beach, Michigan City, and New Buffalo, and is also near a grocery store for convenience.

  • Accommodates 8 guests
  • Beds: 6

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This is one big and gorgeous house! It's perfect for big groups who want to just get away from it all and not have to go anywhere else. It has homey, welcoming rooms, a heated pool, a tub, a large TV... did we mention it's very luxurious? The surroundings are beautiful too!

  • Accommodates 10 guests
  • Beds: 6

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

When you step inside, you'll immediately notice the differently decorated rooms for a nice, whimsical and quirky feeling. Huge spaces and rooms make for a great space for large groups going on getaways. It's fully equipped with modern conveniences and it also has a fireplace area. Walking distance to the beach and dog-friendly (for a fee).

  • Accommodates 10 guests
  • Beds: 5

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The beautifully designed house has a rustic feel with modern touches, making you feel right at home. You will have a tranquil stay with a great view of the woods. The beach is a 15 minute walk, while other places are just 10 minute drives away. It's a bike-friendly space too!

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

You can "rough it" but stay in luxury at the same time with this huge place. It's located in the woods and features a huge yard, a pool, a fire place, and a hot tub. The location is also convenient: just take 10 min drives to Sawyer, Bridgman, Union Pier, or Warren Dunes.

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 4

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The cozy outdoor look hides stylish and comfortable rooms inside. It's pet friendly and it's a true getaway, located on a quiet street and surrounded by plenty of trees. If you want to go out, the space a half mile from downtown New Buffalo and one mile to the beach.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

It is a cozy and charming getaway from everything. One thing you'll really enjoy here is the fireplace - very romantic! This location is a walk away from the beach or nature trails.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This private cottage is cozy, beautifully furbished, and filled with modern amenities, perfect for small families. It is just steps away from restaurants and shopping and a mere 0.7 mile walk to the beach. Get the chance to spot wildlife from the screened-in porch with a view of the woods.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

Comfort Airbnb Rentals Near New Buffalo, Michigan

This cute cottage is charming! You'll love the vintage themed designs inside and the beautiful scenes and views of nature outdoors. Its location is convenient with a bakery, store, and beach within walking distance, while hiking locations and the lake is only a 10 minute drive.

  • Accommodates 8 guests
  • Beds: 7

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This space is so welcoming and relaxing, you may never want to leave! Comfortable beds, welcoming and homey interiors, a patio with a nice view... you name it, this getaway has it. But if you do want to go out, the location is just a few minutes walk to shops, restaurants, and event venues.

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This is a nice big space for a getaway in the middle of the woods. You can go on long walks in the forest and also check out the lake or beach nearby. Return to the house for a cozy night in or drive to nearby restaurants and other establishments.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 4

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The house is thoughtfully designed, and has some beautiful light coming in. It is charming and comfortable with modern amenities. The best part is that this space is only a block away from the beach! Stay with the family to unwind and relax.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This is one stunning cottage in the middle of a beautiful place with awesome light and big spaces. It has a rustic feel with all the modern essentials needed. The space is also just a mile and half away from the beach; is close to Union Pier's restaurants; and minutes away from New Buffalo & Three Oaks.

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This incredible space, made to look like a chalet from Switzerland, is handcrafted and made with wood grown from the property itself. A true work of art! It's clean and cozy and a perfect place to spot beautiful sunsets. Has a hot tub too!

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This space has nice, well-maintained outdoor areas and super welcoming interiors. It's also a very quiet place, so it's perfect to get away from it all. You will be about a block away from the beach and a half mile away from Union Pier - a great location.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

You will immediately get charmed by the bright light and nice touches of color in the design of this space. It's great for large groups of couple retreat and as a vacation spot. It's conveniently located too, even if it's somewhat tucked away, with it being only a half mile walk to the beach and all the restaurants and shop just a few blocks away from the location.

  • Accommodates 8 guests
  • Beds: 5

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

It's a nice and welcoming location in the middle of the woods with the modern essentials. Unwind by just enjoying solitude or checking out the book collection. Enjoy sleeping in the hammock surrounded by beautiful views and very cozy interiors. This is also a pet-friendly place!

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This space is perfect for a nice, quiet holiday with your family (and your pet, for a fee) and not be disturbed by anyone. It is surrounded by trees and has homey, rustic interiors. You can hike, birdwatch, and even let your kids swing on the included swing set.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

Budget Airbnb Rentals Near New Buffalo, Michigan

Reconnect with nature in this private cabin in the middle of the woods. Everything is designed to be welcoming and homey, with endless beautful views of nature and the forrest. Great for a romantic getaway or for small families who like to hike and explore.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

Stayng in this beautiful, cozy cottage is amazing. It's surrounded by trees and semi-private so it's perfect if you're looking for some quiet and relaxing family time. This location is also a short drive away from everything and a 15 minute walk to the beach.

  • Accommodates 8 guests
  • Beds: 5

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The space is big, well-lit, clean and dog-friendly. You'll feel right at home with the nicely decorated interiors and comfortable beds. It's also near the town and a drive away from the beach!

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The design of the space lets a lot of nice soft light come in the house. Coupled with that are the tasteful, homey decor for a nice welcoming and relaxing feeling. A super comfortable place located near Warren Dunes Park.

  • Accommodates 4 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The space has charming vintage details and decors! It will definitely get you reminscing about the good old times while you bask in the nice, warm light coming in. Great trails and the beach are near, and it is also only a 3 minute drive to downtown Sawyer.

  • Accommodates 3 guests
  • Beds: 1

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

It's a relaxing and comfortable place ideal for a couple getaway - but you can bring your dogs along. Enjoy the homey feels of the house where you can just slow down even for a few days. If you want to explore the outdoors, get the chance to spot different kinds of birds and see the nearby beautiful stream.

  • Accommodates 2 guests
  • Beds: 1

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

The interiors boast of beautiful natural light, comfortable and homey interiors, and a cool feature: a ladder leads up to the third story bedroom! This condo is conveniently located near the beach, and also has a lot of nearby walking trails. If you enjoy hiking, biking, checking out wineries and breweries or just hanging out to unwind, this is the perfect place to get away, even if only for the weekend.

  • Accommodates 3 guests
  • Beds: 2

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

This is a place that's perfect to get when you want to explore Three Oaks. Bring along friends and just walk to experience different happenings downtown. Retire afterwards in spacious, comfortable bedrooms and very clean interiors.

  • Accommodates 7 guests
  • Beds: 6

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb

Bring your pets to this charming tiny house - it has a fenced in yard that's perfect for them. It's a nice place for a cozy little getaway to recharge. It's also great location with the beach and downtown New Buffalo within walking distance.

  • Accommodates 6 guests
  • Beds: 3

Image of Airbnb rental in New Buffalo, Michigan

Images: Airbnb